A well-designed diagnostic gene panel is essential for effectively diagnosing genetic disorders while minimizing unnecessary testing and potential patient anxiety. Such panels should prioritize maximizing clinical sensitivity and specificity while also considering clinical validity and utility.
Clinical sensitivity, determined by both biomedical knowledge and technical capabilities, ensures that the panel can accurately detect relevant gene-disease associations. This involves including all genes associated with the disorder to maximize sensitivity while minimizing variants of uncertain significance (VUS). However, careful consideration is needed to balance comprehensive testing with the risk of generating large numbers of VUS, which can complicate patient management.
Clinical specificity is crucial for matching a patient’s clinical features with the appropriate genes, thereby reducing the likelihood of detecting irrelevant variants and minimizing VUS. Gene panels should be tailored to specific phenotypes to enhance specificity, and for disorders with extreme genetic heterogeneity, broader tests like exome or genome sequencing may be more suitable initially.
Clinical validity is crucial for establishing the strength of evidence for gene-disease associations. Laboratories must regularly evaluate the evidence and adjust variant classifications, accordingly, ensuring that variants are interpreted accurately based on the available evidence.
In constructing diagnostic gene panels, it’s essential to include genes with strong evidence for the clinical indication while also considering the intended use of the test (e.g., diagnostic, predictive, or carrier screening). Additionally, panels should be periodically updated to incorporate new gene discoveries and evidence, with clear communication of any genes of uncertain significance included in the test description.
Ultimately, a well-designed diagnostic gene panel optimizes clinical sensitivity and specificity while ensuring accurate and clinically relevant variant interpretation, thus facilitating effective diagnosis and management of genetic disorders.